A young University Student named Bud Corliss is dismayed when his girlfriend Dorrie reveals she’s pregnant. Not looking forward to eking out a living supporting a child he does not want, he engineers Dorrie’s death and makes it looks like a suicide. Dorrie’s death arouses the suspicions of her older sister who investigates privately, while getting ready for marriage to her beau, Bud Corliss…
As someone who only knows Robert Wagner from such classic seventies chess like the TV series Hart to Hart, it’s a bit of a shock to see him as a charismatic young sociopath here, because he’s so good at it. In fact the film suffers in the second half when he isn’t the sole focus anymore, as after he finally is able to achieve the death of Dorrie while making it look like a suicide, that the film suffers. Virginia Leith is fine as Dorrie’s older much more capable sister (who looked annoyingly familiar to me until I realized Ms. Leith was also the severed head that is the true star of the misnomered The Brain Who Wouldn’t Die), but since this is the 1950s it means there has to be a nominal male hero, and that comes in the personage of a big lummox of a police detective in Clark Kent glasses and silly pipe-smoking affectation played by Jeffrey Hunter. Hunter’s a fine actor (who nowadays is more known for being Captain Pike on the unsold pilot for Star Trek instead of being John Wayne’s co-star in The Searchers), but here you can’t help but laugh at the guy as the character he plays is also a condescending, dense, arrogant twit…and those are presented as his good points.
Still the film is trying to be a Hitchcockian thriller, and for that first half it damn near succeeds at being as good as old Hitch. Due to all around behind-the-scenes quality like Lionel Newman’s Bernard Herrmann-esque score to the lush Technicolor cinematography that features such eye-popping treats like Cherry-Red convertibles and deep blue swimming pools to the clever direction from Gerd Oswald (responsible for some of the most twisted and nightmarish episodes of the early 60s Outer Limits, as well as a later film noir The Screaming Mimi, which features a plot twist borrowed by Dario Argento and a hundred of his imitators for the 1970s cycle of giallo thrillers from Italy).
As much as I enthuse about this film, I was struck by its focus on beautiful young rising stars (to the point of gratuitous long shots of a swimsuit-clad Virginia Leith sunning herself) and not terribly complex story, that in many ways it’s a predecessor to later teen-focused thrillers like Disturbia, Cruel Intentions or (god help us) swimfan
Don’t let that scare you off, even with the subpar second half, this is still the best and most worth your while.